When the topic of smart technology comes up, garage door openers probably aren’t the first thing that comes to mind. However, brands like Genie and Chamberlain offer some pretty intelligent products with a surprising number of features. While both openers have a lot going for them, we do feel that the Genie has an slight edge due to integration with HomeLink and Car2U.
Although the Genie does have those extra features going for it, the comparison is honestly a bit of a toss up due to the useful battery backup that the Chamberlain has to offer — firmly cementing it as a top of the line model as well. No matter the brand you choose, you’ll be in and out of your garage with more convenience and ease than ever before.
Below, we give our comprehensive comparison of the Genie vs. Chamberlain garage door opener. If you’re interested in specific features, however, feel free to use our navigation bar to jump directly to the spots you care about most.
Genie vs. Chamberlain Garage Door Opener — Things in Common
3/4 HPS DC Belt Drive System – All the smart features in the world don’t make much of a difference if the physical capabilities of the garage door opener aren’t there. You want to make sure your tech has the power it needs to lift a garage door, as some homes have doors that are quite heavy.
Rest assured, you shouldn’t have any issues on a power front with either model due to the handy ¾ HPS DC Belt Drive System which is more than capable of lifting up most any door.
Ultra Quiet Performance – There’s little worse than coming home late at night and waking up the entire house with the garage door opening. Fortunately, both the Genie and Chamberlain offer ultra quiet performance that will get your door lifted up without disturbing the entire neighborhood.
The Genie comes with a 140V DC motor that is lightweight and provides a super quiet and smooth operation. There’s also a soft start and stop feature built into the motor that ensures smooth garage door travel. It’s a significant improvement over traditional AC motors.
The Chamberlain opener blends power with noiseless operation. The steel-reinforced belt drive and Chamberlain’s Motor Vibration Isolation System essential eliminate powerhead vibration for much less noise.
Safety Sensors – The last thing you want is for your garage door to close on an obstacle or even a person, so having powerful sensors is important.
The Chamberlain features safety sensors that will reliably stop the door from closing on obstructions, and the Genie projects an invisible beam across the door opening — stopping and reversing the door if any object is detected.
Installation – One downside that both the Genie and Chamberlain share is the fact that installation is tricky and complicated. The company provides quality DIY instructions for those feeling particularly ambitious, but most homeowners will probably want to opt for expert installation.
Genie vs. Chamberlain Garage Door Opener — Differences
Difference #1: HomeLink® & Car2U® Compatibility – HomeLink and Car2U offer the majority of the smart features for these products, and the disparity in compatibility is one of the biggest differences when comparing the Genie vs. Chamberlain garage door opener.
The Genie definitely has the edge in this regard, with compatibility for any HomeLink or Car2U systems — regardless of when those systems were made. You don’t need any external equipment like a repeater box or compatibility bridge, and the opener will sync quite easily with the tech in your car.
The Chamberlain does work with these two features but has limited compatibility with cars running Homelink 3.0 or earlier. If you have Homelink 4.0, chances are that you’ll be more than fine. For older cars that don’t have the latest tech, however, you’ll need to use a Repeater Kit.
So, if you have a newer car with all the latest features, there isn’t a significant difference between the two models in this category. For the best chance of having everything work seamlessly, however, you’re definitely better off with the Genie.
Difference #2: Battery Backup – The Chamberlain Whisper Drive with MyQ Technology and Battery Backup allow you to use your garage door even if the power goes out. This is one of the most important features of any garage door openers, as losing access to your stowed car because of an outage can really make it difficult to go about your day. The built-in battery backup on the Chamberlain will charge 24/7 while it’s connected with the AC outlet and will kick in automatically as soon as power is cut.
The Genie also has an option for battery backup, but you’ll need to purchase it separately. Since it’s not built in, it’s not nearly as convenient as the Chamberlain model and it also adds a decent amount of extra expense.
Difference #3: Smart Control – The Genie and Chamberlain garage door openers are both good in terms of smart control, they just approach adding an extra feature in different ways.
The Genie’s smart features are primarily controlled through Aladdin Connect. This smart tech, purchased separately, adds in a bunch of convenience and utility that really separates the Genie apart from a traditional garage door opener.
In addition to easily being able to check whether your garage door is open or closed, there’s a wide range of useful features that really make Aladdin Connect worth the buy.
For example, you can instantly know when someone is opening your garage door — whether that’s a trusted person or an intruder. You can also be alerted when someone is manually opening the door, allowing you to easily start the process of finding out who and why. The extra security features really help keep your home safe, and adds protection to the area of the house that is often neglected when building out a security system.
In terms of added convenience, you’ll be able to easily open the door for anyone like a delivery or repair person, relatives, or friends. Just have them give you a call or text upon their arrival and press a simple button to gain access.
If you’d like to review access later on, there’s also a history of when the door was used, including dates and specific times. This is great for monitoring access to your home, and making sure your garage door is only used the way you intend it.
Chamberlain’s smart functionality is handled through the company’s MyQ Smartphone Control Technology that gives you the ability to control your garage door opener from anywhere in the world as long as you have an iOS or Android device. You’ll simply need the opener and an Internet Gateway, as well as the MyQ Home Control App. Just like the Genie, you’ll be able to receive notifications upon access and remotely control the door — adding some extra convenience and the peace of mind that your home is well-protected.
Genie vs. Chamberlain Garage Door Opener — Comparison Chart
|Genie SilentMax 1200||Chamberlain B730/WD962|
|Battery Backup||Sold Separately||Included|
|Smart Control||via Aladdin Connect||via Internet Gateway|
|HomeLink® & Car2U® Compatibility||Works with ALL HomeLink and Car2U systems||Only with newer models|
|Ultra Quiet Performance||Yes||Yes|
|3/4 HPS DC Belt Drive System||Yes||Yes|
Genie vs. Chamberlain Garage Door Opener — Accessories
There are some great accessories you might want to keep in mind when shopping for your garage door opener that enhance the functionality and add extra convenience. While you don’t need any of these accessories to control your opener, they’re nice to have and you’ll definitely enjoy the enhancements that they have to offer.
While the Genie is compatible with most garage doors by default, buying the Genie EKBC C Channel Belt Extension Kit gives you the tools you need to fit even large garage doors without any worry. Since the garage door opener doesn’t come with an extra battery by default, purchasing the Genie Battery Backup Unit is a great idea to make up for that shortcoming. Lastly, the Genie LED Garage Door Opener Light Bulb ensures you’re never left in the dark when accessing or leaving your garage.
Chamberlain’s accessory line is a little bit larger and more useful and is built of MyQ accessories that enhance the smart features that the garage door opener has to offer. The opener supports up to 8 MyQ compatible accessories, so you’ll have the ability to mix and match to get the setup you most desire. All Security+ 2.0 and MyQ labeled accessories work — even including LiftMaster accessories — so you have a lot of flexibility when it comes to how you’d like to customize your opener. We’ve compiled a list of a few of our favorites, but there are a lot of options out there worthy of your consideration.
The Liftmaster 829LM Garage Door Monitor will work with up to 4 doors, beeping and lighting up when any door opens or remains open. You can close all your garage doors with the press of a single button, and it doesn’t require any additional sensors on the doors themselves. This is a great tool to have on hand for homes with multiple garage doors, as it gives you a central monitoring system and an easy way to close all entrances at will.
The Liftmaster 828LM Garage Door Opener Internet Gateway allows you to take advantage of the MyQ features that the line has to offer and opens up that great smartphone functionality that makes owning a Chamberlain openers so great. Simply plug the gateway into an ethernet port on your router, and it will communicate to Chamberlain’s servers and pass on commands to the garage door opener itself.
The Liftmaster 825LM Remote Light Control is essentially a bulb you can control through the Liftmaster gateway using your phone, which is perfect for adding smart lighting to your garage without having to invest in a whole separate system. Alternatively, you could purchase the Liftmaster 823LM Remote Light Switch in order to add smart control to up to 300 watts of traditional lighting.
Genie vs. Chamberlain Garage Door Opener — Our Thoughts
When comparing the Genie vs. Chamberlain Garage Door Opener, it’s difficult to make a clear decision one way or the other. The Genie is a perfect pick for those who want to take advantage of HomeLink and Car2U compatibility, as it’s much more flexible on that front than the Chamberlain model that only works with more recent systems. On the other hand, the Chamberlain model comes with a built-in battery backup that is built in rather than sold as an additional accessory.
We suppose that the differences that may swing your decision in one direction or the other are in the smart controls, which are different between the two models without either necessarily being better. While the Genie requires the purchase of an Aladdin Connect system, once you have that controller you’ll have access to the full range of smart features. The Chamberlain, on the other hand, has a bit of an edge in features but requires the purchase of a number of different accessories that we detailed in the section above.
Ultimately, we think you’ll be happy with either model. They both represent some of the best that the industry has to offer, and the best one for you is really going to depend on the features that matter most.
Last update on 2020-01-17 at 12:19 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API